Causal orders, quantum circuits and spacetime: distinguishing between definite and superposed causal orders

Nikola Paunković; Marko Vojinović

doi:10.22331/q-2020-05-28-275

Causal orders, quantum circuits and spacetime: distinguishing between definite and superposed causal orders

¹Instituto de Telecomunicações and Departamento de Matemática, Instituto Superior Técnico, Universidade de Lisboa, Avenida Rovisco Pais 1049-001, Lisboa, Portugal
²Institute of Physics, University of Belgrade, Pregrevica 118, 11080 Belgrade, Serbia

Published:	2020-05-28, volume 4, page 275
Eprint:	arXiv:1905.09682v5
Doi:	https://doi.org/10.22331/q-2020-05-28-275
Citation:	Quantum 4, 275 (2020).

Find this paper interesting or want to discuss? Scite or leave a comment on SciRate.

Abstract

We study the notion of causal orders for the cases of (classical and quantum) circuits and spacetime events. We show that every circuit can be immersed into a classical spacetime, preserving the compatibility between the two causal structures. Using the process matrix formalism, we analyse the realisations of the quantum switch using 4 and 3 spacetime events in classical spacetimes with fixed causal orders, and the realisation of a gravitational switch with only 2 spacetime events that features superpositions of different gravitational field configurations and their respective causal orders. We show that the current quantum switch experimental implementations do not feature superpositions of causal orders between spacetime events, and that these superpositions can only occur in the context of superposed gravitational fields. We also discuss a recently introduced operational notion of an event, which does allow for superpositions of respective causal orders in flat spacetime quantum switch implementations. We construct two observables that can distinguish between the quantum switch realisations in classical spacetimes, and gravitational switch implementations in superposed spacetimes. Finally, we discuss our results in the light of the modern relational approach to physics.

► BibTeX data

@article{Paunkovic2020causalorders,
  doi = {10.22331/q-2020-05-28-275},
  url = {https://doi.org/10.22331/q-2020-05-28-275},
  title = {Causal orders, quantum circuits and spacetime: distinguishing between definite and superposed causal orders},
  author = {Paunkovi{\'{c}}, Nikola and Vojinovi{\'{c}}, Marko},
  journal = {{Quantum}},
  issn = {2521-327X},
  publisher = {{Verein zur F{\"{o}}rderung des Open Access Publizierens in den Quantenwissenschaften}},
  volume = {4},
  pages = {275},
  month = may,
  year = {2020}
}

► References

[1] A. Einstein, B. Podolsky and N. Rosen, Physical Review 47, 777 (1935).
https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRev.47.777

[2] J. S. Bell, Physics Physique Fizika 1, 195 (1964).
https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysicsPhysiqueFizika.1.195

[3] G. Chiribella, G. M. D'Ariano, P. Perinotti and B. Valiron, Physical Review A 88, 022318 (2013).
https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.88.022318

[4] L. M. Procopio, A. Moqanaki, M. Araújo, F. Costa, I. A. Calafell, E. G. Dowd, D. R. Hamel, L. A. Rozema, Č. Brukner and P. Walther, Nature Communications 6, 7913 (2015).
https://doi.org/10.1038/ncomms8913

[5] G. Rubino, L. A. Rozema, A. Feix, M. Araújo, J. M. Zeuner, L. M. Procopio, Č. Brukner and P. Walther, Science Advances 3, e1602589 (2017).
https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.1602589

[6] G. Rubino, L. A. Rozema, F. Massa, M. Araújo, M. Zych, Č. Brukner and P. Walther, arXiv:1712.06884.
arXiv:1712.06884

[7] L. Hardy, Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and Theoretical 40, 3081 (2007).
https://doi.org/10.1088/1751-8113/40/12/s12

[8] O. Oreshkov, F. Costa and Č. Brukner, Nature Communications 3, 1092 (2012).
https://doi.org/10.1038/ncomms2076

[9] M. Araújo, C. Branciard, F. Costa, A. Feix, C. Giarmatzi and Č. Brukner, New Journal of Physics 17, 102001 (2015).
https://doi.org/10.1088/1367-2630/17/10/102001

[10] J. Bavaresco, M. Araújo, Č. Brukner and M. T. Quintino, Quantum 3 176 (2019).
https://doi.org/10.22331/q-2019-08-19-176

[11] P. Allard Guérin, G. Rubino and Č. Brukner, Phys. Rev. A 99 062317 (2019).
https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.99.062317

[12] C. Portmann, C. Matt, U. Maurer, R. Renner and B. Tackmann, IEEE Transactions on Information Theory 63, 3277 (2017).
https://doi.org/10.1109/TIT.2017.2676805

[13] J.-P. W. MacLean, K. Ried, R. W. Spekkens and K. J. Resch, Nature Communications 8, 15149 (2017).
https://doi.org/10.1038/ncomms15149

[14] M. Niedermaier and M. Reuter, Living Rev. Rel. 9, 5 (2006).
https://doi.org/10.12942/lrr-2006-5

[15] M. Zych, F. Costa, I. Pikovski and Č. Brukner, Nature Communications 10, 3772 (2019).
https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-019-11579-x

[16] M. Bauer, American Journal of Physics 82, 1087 (2014).
https://doi.org/10.1119/1.4891193

[17] M. O. Scully and K. Drühl, Physical Review A 25, 2208 (1982).
https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.25.2208

[18] M. O. Scully, B.-G. Englert and H. Walther, Nature 351, 111 (1991).
https://doi.org/10.1038/351111a0

[19] H. Lichtenegger and B. Mashhoon, in The Measurement of Gravitomagnetism: A Challenging Enterprise, edited by L. Iorio, 13, Nova Science Pub Inc, New York (2007).

[20] M. Blagojević, Gravitation and Gauge Symmetries, Institute of Physics Publishing, Bristol (2002).

[21] H. Bondi and J. Samuel, Physics Letters A 228, 121 (1997).
https://doi.org/10.1016/S0375-9601(97)00117-5

[22] A. S. Eddington, Space time and gravitation, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (1921).

[23] C. Misner, K. Thorne and J. Wheeler, Gravitation, W. H. Freeman, San Francisco (1973).

[24] C. Rovelli, Quantum Gravity, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (2004).

[25] J. Janjić, N. Paunković and M. Vojinović, in preparation.

[26] C. Rovelli and F. Vidotto, Covariant Loop Quantum Gravity: An Elementary Introduction to Quantum Gravity and Spinfoam Theory, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (2014).

[27] C. T. Marco Ho, F. Costa, C. Giarmatzi and T. C. Ralph, arXiv:1804.05498.
arXiv:1804.05498

[28] O. Oreshkov, Quantum 3, 206 (2019).
https://doi.org/10.22331/q-2019-12-02-206

[29] R. A. Bertlmann and P. Krammer, Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and Theoretical 41, 235303 (2008).
https://doi.org/10.1088/1751-8113/41/23/235303

Cited by

[1] M. Trassinelli, "Conditional probabilities of measurements, quantum time, and the Wigner's-friend case", Physical Review A 105 3, 032213 (2022).

[2] Huan Cao, Jessica Bavaresco, Ning-Ning Wang, Lee A. Rozema, Chao Zhang, Yun-Feng Huang, Bi-Heng Liu, Chuan-Feng Li, Guang-Can Guo, and Philip Walther, "Semi-device-independent certification of indefinite causal order in a photonic quantum switch", Optica 10 5, 561 (2023).

[3] Zuzana Gavorová, Matan Seidel, and Yonathan Touati, "Topological obstructions to quantum computation with unitary oracles", Physical Review A 109 3, 032625 (2024).

[4] Teodor Strömberg, Peter Schiansky, Marco Túlio Quintino, Michael Antesberger, Lee A. Rozema, Iris Agresti, Časlav Brukner, and Philip Walther, "Experimental superposition of a quantum evolution with its time reverse", Physical Review Research 6 2, 023071 (2024).

[5] Ricardo Faleiro, Nikola Paunkovic, and Marko Vojinovic, "Operational interpretation of the vacuum and process matrices for identical particles", Quantum 7, 986 (2023).

[6] Kyrylo Simonov, Gianluca Francica, Giacomo Guarnieri, and Mauro Paternostro, "Work extraction from coherently activated maps via quantum switch", Physical Review A 105 3, 032217 (2022).

[7] David Felce, Nicetu Tibau Vidal, Vlatko Vedral, and Eduardo O. Dias, "Indefinite causal orders from superpositions in time", Physical Review A 105 6, 062216 (2022).

[8] Natália S. Móller, Bruna Sahdo, and Nelson Yokomizo, "Quantum switch in the gravity of Earth", Physical Review A 104 4, 042414 (2021).

[9] Nikola Paunković and Marko Vojinović, "Equivalence Principle in Classical and Quantum Gravity", Universe 8 11, 598 (2022).

[10] Nick Ormrod, Augustin Vanrietvelde, and Jonathan Barrett, "Causal structure in the presence of sectorial constraints, with application to the quantum switch", Quantum 7, 1028 (2023).

[11] Erickson Tjoa, "Quantum teleportation with relativistic communication from first principles", Physical Review A 106 3, 032432 (2022).

[12] Jian Wei Cheong, Andri Pradana, and Lock Yue Chew, "Communication advantage of quantum compositions of channels from non-Markovianity", Physical Review A 106 5, 052410 (2022).

[13] Yaohao Deng, Shuheng Liu, Xiaojiong Chen, Zhaorong Fu, Jueming Bao, Yun Zheng, Qihuang Gong, Qiongyi He, and Jianwei Wang, "Generalized Indefinite Causal Orders in an Integrated Quantum Switch", Physical Review Letters 135 16, 160202 (2025).

[14] Tein van der Lugt, Jonathan Barrett, and Giulio Chiribella, "Device-independent certification of indefinite causal order in the quantum switch", Nature Communications 14 1, 5811 (2023).

[15] V. Vilasini and Renato Renner, "Fundamental Limits for Realizing Quantum Processes in Spacetime", Physical Review Letters 133 8, 080201 (2024).

[16] Laura J. Henderson, Alessio Belenchia, Esteban Castro-Ruiz, Costantino Budroni, Magdalena Zych, Časlav Brukner, and Robert B. Mann, "Quantum Temporal Superposition: The Case of Quantum Field Theory", Physical Review Letters 125 13, 131602 (2020).

[17] Eduardo A. B. Oliveira and André G. S. Landulfo, "Spacetime-covariant approach to inertial and accelerated quantum clocks in first quantization", Physical Review D 113 4, 045018 (2026).

[18] Natália S. Móller, Bruna Sahdo, and Nelson Yokomizo, "Gravitational quantum switch on a superposition of spherical shells", Quantum 8, 1248 (2024).

[19] Viktoria Kabel, Anne-Catherine de la Hamette, Luca Apadula, Carlo Cepollaro, Henrique Gomes, Jeremy Butterfield, and Časlav Brukner, "Quantum coordinates, localisation of events, and the quantum hole argument", Communications Physics 8 1, 185 (2025).

[20] Carlos Sabín, "Causality in a Qubit-Based Implementation of a Quantum Switch", Universe 8 5, 269 (2022).

[21] Robin Lorenz, "Quantum causal models: the merits of the spirit of Reichenbach’s principle for understanding quantum causal structure", Synthese 200 5, 424 (2022).

[22] Matthias Salzger and V Vilasini, "Mapping indefinite causal order processes to composable quantum protocols in a spacetime", New Journal of Physics 27 2, 023002 (2025).

[23] Qing-Feng Xue, Qi Zhang, Xu-Cai Zhuang, Ying-Jie Zhang, Yun-Jie Xia, Enrico Russo, Giulio Chiribella, Rosario Lo Franco, and Zhong-Xiao Man, "Anomalous Heat Flows and Quantum Otto Engine with (In)definite Causal Order", Physical Review Letters 137 3, 030404 (2026).

[24] Marco Fellous-Asiani, Raphaël Mothe, Léa Bresque, Hippolyte Dourdent, Patrice A. Camati, Alastair A. Abbott, Alexia Auffèves, and Cyril Branciard, "Comparing the quantum switch and its simulations with energetically constrained operations", Physical Review Research 5 2, 023111 (2023).

[25] Joshua Foo and Magdalena Zych, "Superpositions of thermalisations in relativistic quantum field theory", Quantum 9, 1629 (2025).

[26] Aurélien Drezet, "Indefinite causal order with fixed temporal order for electrons and positrons", Quantum Studies: Mathematics and Foundations 10 1, 101 (2023).

[27] Emily Adlam, "Is there causation in fundamental physics? New insights from process matrices and quantum causal modelling", Synthese 201 5, 152 (2023).

[28] Julian Wechs, Hippolyte Dourdent, Alastair A. Abbott, and Cyril Branciard, "Quantum Circuits with Classical Versus Quantum Control of Causal Order", PRX Quantum 2 3, 030335 (2021).

[29] Laurie Letertre, "Temporal nonlocality from indefinite causal orders", The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 734907 (2025).

[30] Yu Guo, Zixuan Liu, Hao Tang, Xiao-Min Hu, Bi-Heng Liu, Yun-Feng Huang, Chuan-Feng Li, Guang-Can Guo, and Giulio Chiribella, "Experimental Demonstration of Input-Output Indefiniteness in a Single Quantum Device", Physical Review Letters 132 16, 160201 (2024).

[31] Michael Kasprzak and Erickson Tjoa, "Transmission of quantum information through quantum fields in curved spacetimes", Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and Theoretical 58 9, 095301 (2025).

[32] Laurie Letertre, "Causal nonseparability and its implications for spatiotemporal relations", Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 95, 64 (2022).

[33] Lee A. Rozema, Teodor Strömberg, Huan Cao, Yu Guo, Bi-Heng Liu, and Philip Walther, "Experimental aspects of indefinite causal order in quantum mechanics", Nature Reviews Physics 6 8, 483 (2024).

[34] V. Vilasini and Renato Renner, "Embedding cyclic information-theoretic structures in acyclic space-times: No-go results for indefinite causality", Physical Review A 110 2, 022227 (2024).

[35] Daniele Cuomo, Springer Theses 15 (2024) ISBN:978-3-031-73807-4.

[36] Samuel Fedida, Anne-Catherine de la Hamette, Viktoria Kabel, and Časlav Brukner, "Knot invariants and indefinite causal order", Quantum 9, 1875 (2025).

[37] Carla M.D. Richter, Michael Antesberger, Huan Cao, Philip Walther, and Lee A. Rozema, "Toward an Experimental Device-Independent Verification of Indefinite Causal Order", PRX Quantum 7 1, 010354 (2026).

[38] Joshua Foo, Cendikiawan Suryaatmadja, Robert B. Mann, and Magdalena Zych, "Relativity and decoherence of spacetime superpositions", npj Quantum Information 12 1, 116 (2026).

[39] Pedro R. Dieguez, Vinicius F. Lisboa, and Roberto M. Serra, "Thermal devices powered by generalized measurements with indefinite causal order", Physical Review A 107 1, 012423 (2023).

[40] Erickson Tjoa and Finnian Gray, "The Unruh–DeWitt model and its joint interacting Hilbert space", Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and Theoretical 57 32, 325301 (2024).

[41] Johannes Jakob Meyer, Sumeet Khatri, Daniel Stilck França, Jens Eisert, and Philippe Faist, "Quantum Metrology in the Finite-Sample Regime", PRX Quantum 6 3, 030336 (2025).

[42] Michael Antesberger, Marco Túlio Quintino, Philip Walther, and Lee A. Rozema, "Higher-Order Process Matrix Tomography of a Passively-Stable Quantum Switch", PRX Quantum 5 1, 010325 (2024).

[43] Alastair A. Abbott, Julian Wechs, Dominic Horsman, Mehdi Mhalla, and Cyril Branciard, "Communication through coherent control of quantum channels", Quantum 4, 333 (2020).

[44] Julian Wechs and Ognyan Oreshkov, "Subsystem Decompositions of Quantum Evolutions and Transformations between Causal Perspectives", Physical Review Letters 135 19, 190201 (2025).

[45] Yu Guo, Hao Tang, Bo-Xuan Wang, Min-Yu Lv, Jia-Wen Fan, Xiao-Min Hu, Yun-Feng Huang, Chuan-Feng Li, Guang-Can Guo, Giulio Chiribella, and Bi-Heng Liu, "Experimental violation of a Bell-like inequality for causal order", Science Advances 12 24, eaee2912 (2026).

[46] Jonathan Barrett, Robin Lorenz, and Ognyan Oreshkov, "Cyclic quantum causal models", Nature Communications 12 1, 885 (2021).

[47] Anne-Catherine de la Hamette, Viktoria Kabel, Marios Christodoulou, and Časlav Brukner, "Indefinite Causal Order and Quantum Coordinates", Physical Review Letters 135 14, 141402 (2025).

[48] Anna Steffinlongo and Hippolyte Dourdent, "Simulating noncausality with quantum control of causal orders", Physical Review Research 8 1, 013127 (2026).

[49] Nicola Pinzani and Stefano Gogioso, "Giving Operational Meaning to the Superposition of Causal Orders", arXiv:2003.13306, (2020).

[50] V. Vilasini, Lin-Qing Chen, Liuhang Ye, and Renato Renner, "Events and their Localisation are Relative to a Lab", arXiv:2505.21797, (2025).

[51] Pablo Arrighi, Marios Christodoulou, and Amélia Durbec, "On quantum superpositions of graphs, no-signalling and covariance", arXiv:2010.13579, (2020).

[52] Hlér Kristjánsson, Tatsuki Odake, Satoshi Yoshida, Philip Taranto, Jessica Bavaresco, Marco Túlio Quintino, and Mio Murao, "Exponential separation in quantum query complexity of the quantum switch with respect to simulations with standard quantum circuits", arXiv:2409.18420, (2024).

[53] Nikola Paunkovic and Marko Vojinovic, "Challenges for extensions of the process matrix formalism to quantum field theory", arXiv:2310.04597, (2023).

[54] Eliot Jean, Ralph Silva, and V. Vilasini, "An equivalence between time-symmetry and cyclic causality in quantum theory", arXiv:2508.02463, (2025).

[55] Augustin Vanrietvelde, Octave Mestoudjian, and Pablo Arrighi, "Partitions in quantum theory", arXiv:2506.22218, (2025).

[56] Julian Wechs and Ognyan Oreshkov, "Subsystem decompositions of quantum evolutions and transformations between causal perspectives", arXiv:2411.16504, (2024).

[57] Carla Ferradini, Giulia Mazzola, and V. Vilasini, "Emergent causal order and time direction: bridging causal models and tensor networks", arXiv:2603.12283, (2026).

[58] Pablo Arrighi, Marios Christodoulou, and Amélia Durbec, "On quantum superpositions of graphs, no-signalling and covariance", Journal of Physics A Mathematical General 58 15, 155303 (2025).

The above citations are from Crossref's cited-by service (last updated successfully 2026-08-08 18:30:33) and SAO/NASA ADS (last updated successfully 2026-08-08 18:30:35). The list may be incomplete as not all publishers provide suitable and complete citation data.

This Paper is published in Quantum under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) license. Copyright remains with the original copyright holders such as the authors or their institutions.